On‘Modern Family,’ Matthew Broderick guest starred as a gay man fresh out of a relationship and cautiously looking for love. Who did he happen to meet at the gym? Phil Dunphy, who was lookin’ for a guys night. A classic sitcom mix-up ensued; especially after Phil accidentally spilled margaritason the two of them. The two had to take off their shirts to stay dry. Matthew Broderick's character, Dave, actually thought things were moving too quickly, so he left, but not before giving Phil a kiss.